Following up with a silent prospect without being pushy
A prospect who doesn't reply hasn't necessarily said no. Often they just forgot. Here's how to follow up twice, cleanly, then move on.
Silence isn't a refusal. Most of the time, your message arrived at the wrong moment and slid under a pile of others. A follow-up isn't pressure: it's a polite reminder.
The two follow-up rule
- Follow-up 1, three to five days later: short, no reproach, with new information or a simple question.
- Follow-up 2, a week later: a closing message that makes "no" easy.
After that, stop. Two well-made follow-ups get an answer far more often than one, and far more politely than five.
Example of a first follow-up
Hi Marc, bumping my message in case it got lost.
Is the question of unanswered quotes still on your plate?
Example of a closing message
Hi Marc, I don't want to clutter your inbox: I'll assume it's not the right time and won't follow up again.
If it becomes a priority, you know where to find me.
This message often gets a reply precisely because it asks for nothing.
What never to do
- Guilt-trip: "I haven't heard back from you…"
- Follow up the next day
- Send exactly the same message again
- Follow up on three different channels the same day
The number to track
The number of firm answers, yes or no, to your follow-ups. A clear no beats a lingering maybe: it frees your time for a prospect who will say yes.
Want help choosing your one action every day?
FounderPulse names your revenue bottleneck, gives you one action for today and the number that proves it worked.
Run the free diagnosticFree diagnostic · no signup · no card